Skip to main content

Power Rankings

The Paddock Report: Zero Games Played, Plenty to Argue About

MLB

Quick housekeeping before the hot takes. No team has played a game in 2026 yet, so there's no win-loss record to be fooled by. This week runs on the net, offensive, and defensive ratings alone. The two All-Star entries at the top carry no numbers, so they sit out the debate.

Start with the best net rating on the board: Milwaukee at +1.3. The Brewers pair a 5.1 offense with a 3.8 defense, a two-way profile bettors should respect. The Dodgers are right behind at +1.2, with a 4.9 offense and a 3.7 defense. Los Angeles and the Yankees share the stingiest run prevention in the group at 3.7.

Now the part that should make you grumble. The Yankees sit at +0.9 net and are ranked dead last at 32nd. The Cubs, also at +0.9, are 10th, and they bring the league's best offense at 5.2. The ratings say New York belongs much higher than its slot, and this column will say so plainly.

Then there's the cellar. The Athletics (-1.5) and Rockies (-1.2) have the worst net numbers, and both carry a 5.8 defense. Oakland at 5th is a generous spot for a team whose numbers show it leaking runs. Colorado at 27th is closer to what the ratings support.

Washington is the odd case: a 5.1 offense, a 5.0 defense, and a net of exactly 0.0. Strong bats, shaky glove, and a middle-of-the-pack profile. Cincinnati's 5.1 defense is just as ugly at -1.0 net.

Bottom line: the ratings back Milwaukee and Los Angeles as the top two real teams, flag New York as the biggest mismatch between slot and numbers, and mark Athletics and Colorado as the teams the data least supports. Once games start, the records will finally give us something to be overrated or underrated against. For now, the numbers are the only scorecard we've got.

Discuss this one with the community in The Stable.
See Today's DarkHorse Picks

Disclaimer & Legal Notice

Dark Horse is a sports analytics and sports entertainment platform. All content, insights, projections, and data provided by Dark Horse are offered for sports entertainment and informational purposes only. Dark Horse does not provide financial, investment, or wagering advice and does not guarantee any outcomes. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Users are solely responsible for how they interpret and use the information presented on the platform.

Dark Horse does not accept wagers, facilitate betting transactions, or operate as a sportsbook. The platform provides analytical tools and insights only, and does not engage in gambling activities of any kind.

If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, help is available. Please contact the National Problem Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700 or visit www.ncpgambling.org for confidential support and resources.

By accessing or using Dark Horse, you acknowledge and agree to these terms.